The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Middle content
Book cover
Book Clubs
Click here to view the Reading Group Guide, Potato Peel Pie Recipe and much more for your book clubs!
Buy Guernsey
Add to Shelf:
Good Reads
Library Thing
E-mail Alerts
Join the Random House Readers Circle mailing list and receive the latest news about Guernsey!
Recent Posts
  • January 2010
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • Divider
  • Divider

    Week 6 Essay Winner!


    A novel by David Maine

    Submitted by Dianne Snell 

    My favorite book?  Please!!  That’s like asking a mother to pick her favorite kid!  I have read—just guessing— hundreds of books in my near-70 years (Okay, 65 years since I couldn’t read until age 5) and you ask me to pick my favorite?  Even so, in order to enter the contest, I decided to choose one book I have read and write an essay on it.


    I never read books that I don’t like.  I may start one but never finish it.  A recent book that I finished—therefore liked—was “The Preservationist” by David Maine.  Not my usual reading fare, but in his new slant on this ancient tale Maine captured my imagination with his vivid descriptions of the insurmountable problems faced by “Noe” as he obeyed God’s commands without question.


    I learned the Bible story of Noah and the flood early in life, but until Bill Cosby came out with his comedy version back in the 1960’s I never really questioned the premise of a 500-year-old man building a huge boat to save his family and two of each kind of animal from a flood that was to cover the entire earth.


    First Cosby, and now Maine, started me pondering the logistics of such a colossal undertaking.  In Cosby’s version. God said, “Noah, I want you to build an ark.” Noah said, “Okay Lord.” (pause) “What’s an ark?” (laughter).  “The ark is to be 300 cubits long.”  “Okay Lord.” (pause) “What’s a cubit?” (laughter)


    Maine’s version reads more like a reality show, only with more reality!  Hear “the wife” questioning in Part One: “So when Himself starts with the visions and the holy labors and the boat full of critters, what am I supposed to do? Talk sense? Ask questions he can’t answer, like, How do you propose to keep the lions from eating the goats? Or us for that matter? No thanks. I just fuss with the stew and keep my thoughts stitched up in my head where they belong. Long ago I quit asking questions.”  What wife doesn’t relate to that kind of logic?


    The astounding thing about “The Preservationist?” I expected a farce, but the more I read the more logical it became until I could almost believe that the events happened just like the author said. Impossibilities were explained away and made to seem entirely possible.  Maine managed to allot a distinct personality to each character and I found myself playing favorites among the sons and daughters-in-law.


    “The Preservationist” was a fascinating read, and I have already ordered Maine’s “Sampson” to see what take he puts on that familiar story.



    Tags: , , ,

    2 Responses to “Week 6 Essay Winner!”

    1. Irma Fritz says:

      What a joy to read your essay of The Preservationist! You’ve intrigued me enough to check it out.

    2. グッチ バッグ says:

      グッチ バッグ…

      [...]The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society » Week 6 Essay Winner![...]…

    Leave a Reply

    Dial PressRandom House Audio
    Copyright © 2009 Random House LLC. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Webmaster
    This site is powered by WordPress MU