About this guide
The questions, discussion topics, and suggested reading list that follow are
intended to enhance your group's reading of Haruki Murakami's Norwegian
Wood. We hope they will lead to a richer understanding of this remarkable
novel. Set in Tokyo in the late sixties, Norwegian Wood explores the
life of Toru Watanabe, a solitary and anguished young student, as he struggles to
find himself, to recover from the suicide of his best friend, and to choose
between the two women he loves, Naoko and Midori. At seventeen, after an ordinary
evening playing pool, Watanabe's friend Kizuki kills himself, an act that plunges
Naoko, Kizuki's companion since childhood, into a depression from which she never
fully emerges. In their grief, Naoko and Watanabe are drawn together. But Naoko's
depression worsens, she enters a sanitarium in the mountains near Kyoto, and
Watanabe, to ease his loneliness, joins a hedonistic fellow student, Nagasawa, in
pursuit of meaningless sexual encounters. Then he meets Midori, a vibrant, wildly
unpredictable, and fiercely emotional young woman who will complicate his loyalty
to Naoko and offer him a love that he says "stands and walks on its own, living
and breathing and throbbing and shaking me to the roots of my being" [p. 268].
Torn between his vow to help Naoko recover and his desire to begin a more hopeful
relationship with Midori, Watanabe vacillates. He visits Naoko in the asylum, an
otherworldly place where doctors and patients are nearly interchangeable, but at
the same time deepens his connection with Midori, who demands a profound
commitment from him. His choice, and the tragic conclusion to Naoko's suffering
that follows it, impel Watanabe into a period of desperate wandering, from which
he returns with a deeper self-understanding and a firm resolve to begin his life
anew. An elegiac novel that explores the aftermath of suicide, mental
illness, and death, Norwegian Wood is also a sharply observed and often
hilarious commentary on Japanese society and university life during a time of
widespread student activism and protest. Most of all, it is a bittersweet
meditation on friendship, memory, and the elusive, shifting nature of love.
For discussion
- When Watanabe arrives in Hamburg and hears the song "Norwegian Wood,"
memories of a scene with Naoko from eighteen years before come back to him. He
feels these memories as "kicks" and says they were "longer and harder than usual.
Which is why I am writing this book. To think. To understand. . . . I have to
write things down to feel I fully understand them" [p. 5]. Why does this
particular song have such a powerful effect on Watanabe? What does he
understand--or fail to understand--about it by the end of the novel? In what ways
does the process of writing help in understanding?
- Many readers and
critics have observed that Norwegian Wood is Murakami's most autobiographical
book. While we can never know exactly to what degree a work of fiction reflects
the lived experience of its author, what qualities of the novel feel
autobiographical rather than purely fictional? Do these qualities enhance your
enjoyment of the book?
- After Watanabe sleeps with Naoko, he says that
"her cry was the saddest sound of orgasm I had ever heard" [p. 40]. Just before
she commits suicide, Naoko tells Reiko: "I just don't want anybody going inside
me again. I just don't want to be violated like that again--by anybody" [p. 284].
In what sense did Watanabe "violate" her? Do you feel this experience directly
relates to her suicide? Was it, as Watanabe still asks himself nearly twenty
years later, "the right thing to do"?
- Throughout the novel, Watanabe is
powerfully drawn to both Naoko and Midori. How are these women different from one
another? How would you describe the different kinds of love they offer Watanabe?
Why do you think he finally chooses Midori? Has he made the right choice?
- The events Norwegian Wood relates take place in the late sixties, a period of
widespread student unrest. The university Watanabe attends is frequently beset
with protests and strikes and, in Watanabe's view, pompous "revolutionary"
speeches filled with meaningless clichˇs. "The true enemy of this bunch,"
Watanabe thinks, "was not State Power but Lack of Imagination" [p. 57]. At first,
he identifies with the student protesters but then grows cynical. What qualities
of Watanabe's character make this cynicism inevitable? What is Midori's reaction
to student activism?
- How would you describe Watanabe's friend Nagasawa? What is his view of life,
of the right way to live? Why is Watanabe drawn to him? In what important
ways--particularly in their treatment of women--are they different? How does
Murakami use the character of Nagasawa to define Watanabe more sharply?
- The Great Gatsby is Watanabe's favorite book, one that he rereads often. Why
do you think he identifies so strongly with Fitzgerald's novel? What does this
identification reveal about his character and his worldview?
- In many ways, Norwegian Wood is a novel about young people struggling to find
themselves and survive their various troubles. Kizuki, Hatsumi, Naoko's sister,
and Naoko herself fail in this struggle and commit suicide. How do their deaths
affect those they leave behind? In what ways does Kizuki's suicide both deepen
and tragically limit Watanabe's relationship with Naoko?
- Murakami's prose rises at times to an incandescent lyricism. The description
of Watanabe embracing Naoko is one such instance: "From shoulder to back to hips,
I slid my hand again and again, driving the line and the softness of her body
into my brain. After we had been in this gentle embrace for a while, Naoko
touched her lips to my forehead and slipped out of bed. I could see her pale blue
gown flash in the darkness like a fish" [p. 163]. Where else do you find this
poetic richness in Norwegian Wood? What does such writing add to the novel? What
does it tell us about Watanabe's sensibility?
- At the center of the novel, Reiko tells the long and painful story of how her
life was ruined by a sexual relationship with a young and pathologically
dishonest female student. How does this story within the story illuminate other
relationships in the novel?
- What is unusual about the asylum where Reiko and Naoko are staying? What
methods of healing are employed there? How do the asylum and the principles on
which it is run illuminate the concerns about being "normal" that nearly all the
characters in the novel express?
- Naoko attributes Kizuki's suicide and her own depression to the fact that
they shared such an idyllic childhood together and eventually, as adults, had to
pay the price for that early happiness. "We didn't pay when we should have, so
now the bills are due" [p. 128]. Do you think this is an accurate way of
understanding what's happened to them? What alternative explanations would you
propose?
- After Kizuki and Naoko have both committed suicide, Watanabe writes: "I had
learned one thing from Kizuki's death, and I believed that I had made it part of
myself in the form of a philosophy: 'Death is not the opposite of life but an
innate part of life'" [p. 273]. What do you think he means? Is this view of life
and death resigned or affirmative? How would such a philosophy change one's
approach to life?
- What makes Midori such an engaging and forceful character? How is she
different from everyone else in the novel? What kind of love does she demand from
Watanabe? Is she being selfish in her demands or simply asking for what everyone
wants but is afraid to pursue?
- Norwegian Wood appears to end on a happy note with Watanabe calling Midori
and telling her: "All I want in the world is you. . . . I want the two of us to
begin everything from the beginning" [p. 293]. But when Midori asks where he is,
Watanabe is plunged into a kind of existential confusion. How do you interpret
the novel's final mysterious sentence: "Again and again, I called out for Midori
from the dead center of this place that was no place." Is there anything positive
in Watanabe's not knowing "where he is"? What is the significance of his being at
the "dead center" of no place, wishing for a new beginning?
- The events of the novel take place in the fictional past. What can you infer
about Watanabe's present condition from the way he tells this story? Do you
imagine that he and Midori have remained together?
Suggestions for further reading Kobo Abe, The Woman in the Dunes; Osamu
Dazai, Self-Portraits; F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby; James Joyce, A
Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man; Yasunari Kawabata, Thousand Cranes; Thomas
Mann, The Magic Mountain; Yukio Mishima, The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the
Sea; Kenzaburo Oe, A Personal Matter; J.D. Salinger, The Catcher in the Rye;
Natsume Soseki, Kokoro; Junichiro Tanizaki, The Makioka Sisters; Banana
Yoshimoto, Amrita.
|